Ok.... Idol auditions?

Like ones that wernt painfull. But they wernt amazing either. I thought that Star Wars girl Christina wasnt that bad of a singer. Did you think so? The ones with those three girls on roller skates? The girl HEather who didnt make it ( She sang God Bless the Broken Road) THey said she was good but not great. Our their any other singers who auditioned like that. names please?